We use cookies where necessary to allow us to understand how people interact with our website and content, so that we can continue to improve our service.
We only ever receive anonymous information, and cannot track you across other websites.
View our privacy policy
Parties like Reform have a clear message on why living standards are collapsing. And this is why they're growing.
This is an AI-written (but human-edited) summary of Gary’s recent video: Why are the far right doing so well? And can it be stopped?
Across the UK and Europe, far-right parties are surging. Reform are ahead in UK national polls. The AfD doubled its vote share in Germany. The mainstream response has oscillated between dismissal, alarm, and increasingly desperate attempts at imitation.
Gary’s argument is that all of these responses share the same flaw. They are focused on the wrong question. The question is not how to discredit the far right. The question is why they are winning — and that has a clear answer almost no mainstream politician is willing to say out loud.
Far-right parties are growing because living standards are falling, and they are the only political force with a simple, widely understood story about why. That story — it’s the immigrants, it’s the foreigners — is factually wrong. But it is clear, it is repeated constantly, and it speaks directly to the experience of people whose lives have genuinely become harder.
We can stop growing wealth inequality.
The far right are not winning on the strength of their economic programme, which is largely incoherent. They are winning on the strength of their diagnosis. Until someone else offers a competing explanation that is equally simple and equally rooted in lived experience, the far right will continue to fill the vacuum.
Reform are not just polling well nationally — they have begun winning at local level, including a significant by-election victory in Manchester. The trajectory is rising, and the conditions producing it — stagnant wages, unaffordable housing, collapsing public services — are not improving.
Gary places this in its historical context. British politics has been dominated by centrist parties for roughly two hundred years. That era, he argues, is now ending. What happened to the Conservative vote is not a one-off. It is what happens when a party loses the ability to offer a credible account of how it will improve people’s material lives. Labour, Gary warns, is on the same trajectory.
Gary is direct about what he sees as the strategic failure of the progressive side of politics. The left and centre are divided while the far right operates with a unified message. He is not arguing for the left to abandon its values. He is arguing for something more basic: a recognition that disagreements within the progressive coalition are second-order questions compared to whether living standards will continue to fall. If they do, the far right wins regardless. The priority has to be the economy.
Gary describes the current moment as the last realistic opportunity for mainstream and progressive politics to reclaim the argument before the slide becomes irreversible. Each election the far right win, they gain incumbency advantages and media legitimacy. The window for a compelling counter-narrative narrows with each passing cycle. This is not melodrama — it is what the data from continental Europe already shows.
Two of the sharpest passages in the video are closely connected. The first is Gary’s critique of how the left talks about economics. Academic language and technical jargon are obstacles when the task is to explain to someone why their rent has doubled and their wages haven’t. The far right have understood this. Their messaging is blunt, emotional, and easily repeatable. The left needs to match their clarity, not their dishonesty.
The second is a message Gary directs at his own audience. A significant strand of liberal commentary on the far-right surge involves, implicitly or explicitly, contempt for the people who support it — described as stupid, manipulated, voting against their interests. Gary rejects this entirely. People who have seen their living standards decline and are looking for an explanation are not behaving irrationally. Looking down on them confirms their sense that opponents of the far right don’t actually care about their lives.
Gary speaks directly to people currently supporting Reform. His message is blunt: he understands why they are there. But stopping immigration will not bring down their rent, raise their wages, or fix the NHS. The thing actually causing their lives to get harder is the concentration of wealth at the very top of the economy — and Reform’s policies will make that worse. He says this not with contempt, but as someone who spent his career in finance watching this process happen, who made money from it, and who left specifically because he thought someone needed to explain it clearly and in public.
The video ends with conditional optimism. The public understanding of inequality is growing — including, Gary argues, among people who currently support the far right. Wealth tax proposals command majority support when clearly explained. The far right are rising because the centre has failed, and that is also the reason they can be stopped: because the conditions that produced them can be changed.
Not by fighting them on their own terms. Not by imitating their tactics. By reversing the falling living standards that are their fuel.